📍 Serving Wayne County, Duplin County & Mount Olive, NC
Independent Local Journalism · Wayne County & Duplin County, NC
Courts & Law

DOJ Ethics Watchdog Finds Lawyers Misused AI, Lied to Court

Two DOJ lawyers broke rules by misusing AI in court filings; one lied to a judge, risking disbarment, watchdog reports.

DOJ Ethics Watchdog Finds Lawyers Misused AI, Lied to Court

Uploaded image

The Department of Justice’s internal ethics watchdog has revealed that two of its own lawyers violated professional conduct rules related to artificial intelligence misuse, with one lawyer also making false statements to a court. The findings, released Tuesday by the DOJ’s Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR), could lead to the lawyers facing disbarment proceedings.

Details of the AI Misuse and False Court Statements

The more serious case involves a DOJ lawyer who used AI to draft a court filing containing fabricated quotes. This lawyer then knowingly and intentionally misled the court about the origin of the faulty filing. According to Bloomberg Law, the summary aligns with prior reporting on Rudy Renfer, a veteran civil lawyer in the federal prosecutor’s office in North Carolina. Renfer submitted the erroneous brief while defending the government, was dismissed in March, and was formally reprimanded by a judge for both the flawed filing and his lack of candor.

Second Lawyer Violated Protective Order by Using Public AI

The second unnamed DOJ lawyer got into trouble for uploading protected documents to a publicly accessible AI program, violating a tribunal-issued protective order and department rules. OPR described this conduct as “reckless.” This breach highlights growing concerns about the risks AI poses for confidential legal material and compliance with court orders.

Broader Implications for Government Attorneys and AI Use

These incidents show that worries about AI-generated errors in legal documents have now reached government attorneys. Fake or inaccurate material has previously appeared in government filings, including a DOJ lawyer’s embarrassment over bogus quotations and ICE attorneys citing non-existent cases. Judges have also taken action, such as removing a DOJ lawyer from an immigration case.

Next Steps and Potential Consequences

The OPR forwarded its conclusions to the DOJ’s Professional Misconduct Review Unit, which can recommend state bar disciplinary action, including disbarment. The severity of the violations, particularly the intentional falsehood to the court, places the lawyers on a path toward serious professional repercussions. These developments raise questions about oversight and safeguards regarding AI use in legal practice within the DOJ.

The Department of Justice’s watchdog report underscores the emerging challenges AI presents in the legal field, especially for government lawyers entrusted with upholding the law and ethical standards.

James Fortner Reporter, Mount Olive Chronicle

Covers public safety, courts, and law enforcement. Criminal justice background from Fayetteville State University. The Chronicle's primary FOIA and public records specialist. More →

← Pentagon Prayer Service Led by Pete Hegseth Features Controversial Pastor President Trump Questions Timing of Sharp Gas Price Drop After Midterms →
Mount Olive Chronicle

Independent local news for Wayne County, Duplin County, and the greater Mount Olive community in eastern North Carolina. Founded to serve the people and neighborhoods that deserve consistent, credible coverage.

📧 news@mountolivechronicle.com

📍 Mount Olive, North Carolina 28365

Sections

About

Legal

Search

© Mount Olive Chronicle. All rights reserved. Independent journalism for eastern North Carolina. Not affiliated with the former Mount Olive Tribune.