📍 Serving Wayne County, Duplin County & Mount Olive, NC
Independent Local Journalism · Wayne County & Duplin County, NC
Courts & Law

Judge Orders White House Server Search in Karoline Leavitt Big Law Smear Case

A federal judge orders the White House to produce records tied to Karoline Leavitt’s smear against Big Law firms amid ABA lawsuit.

Judge Orders White House Server Search in Karoline Leavitt Big Law Smear Case

Gage Skidmore from Surprise, AZ, United States of America/Wikimedia Commons

A U.S. District Judge has mandated the Executive Office of the President to turn over drafts, memos, and emails related to White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt’s claims that President Donald Trump was holding major law firms accountable for their “lies.” The order, issued Monday by Judge Amir Ali, demands the White House search its servers for records tied to the directive Leavitt described amid the American Bar Association’s lawsuit challenging Trump’s campaign against Big Law.

Details of the Court Order and Scope of Records Sought

Judge Ali’s ruling requires the White House to produce documents from Feb. 13 through April 18, 2025, the period when President Trump signed five executive orders targeting law firms and nine firms agreed to concessions with his administration. The judge cited Leavitt’s statement to The Wall Street Journal in April 2025, where she said, “President Trump’s policy team is executing on his directive to hold Big Law accountable for their weaponization of justice and their lies, and the strategy has proven tremendously successful.” These words are pivotal in defining the scope of the search.

Ali emphasized that drafts of the executive orders may reveal the government’s motivation, while memos could potentially confirm the existence of an intimidation policy. The judge also noted that emails already produced from the Justice Department’s files show White House aides rushing to lift sanctions on law firm Paul Weiss following Trump’s executive order on March 14, 2025, after the firm made concessions.

The ABA Lawsuit and Government’s Defense

The American Bar Association’s lawsuit centers on allegations that Trump’s campaign against major law firms constituted a coordinated effort of intimidation. Leavitt’s public remarks have been key evidence in the case. On April 9, 2025, she stated, “Big Law continues to bend the knee to President Trump because they know they were wrong,” as cited in the ABA’s complaint.

Government lawyers sought to dismiss the lawsuit last year, arguing the ABA failed to show a plausible policy threatening its members and that any threat had ended by June 2025 when the lawsuit was filed. However, Judge Ali rejected the dismissal in March, citing Leavitt’s “policy team” statement as evidence of a broader effort, which kept the case alive.

White House Resistance and Privilege Claims

The administration has resisted the document requests, arguing the search would disrupt Executive Branch functions and raise separation-of-powers issues. It also refused to identify members of Leavitt’s so-called “policy team,” invoking presidential communications privilege to protect confidential presidential advice. A White House attorney warned that naming these individuals could chill candid discussions.

Judge Ali acknowledged that many of the requested records may be privileged but ordered the parties to agree on search terms and propose a schedule by December 4. He also allowed the possibility of a stay on the order during any appeal.

Implications and Next Steps in the Case

This court order marks a significant development in the ABA’s effort to uncover whether the Trump administration’s actions against Big Law involved intimidation policies. The release of internal White House drafts and memos could shed light on the administration’s motivations and strategies during the critical period of early 2025 when multiple executive orders targeted prominent law firms.

The case continues to unfold with the White House preparing to comply or potentially appeal the ruling. The coming weeks will reveal more as search terms are negotiated and the production schedule is set.

With the judge’s order, the White House faces increased scrutiny over its aggressive stance toward major law firms, a move that has sparked legal battles and raised questions about executive overreach and the use of presidential power.

James Fortner Reporter, Mount Olive Chronicle

Covers public safety, courts, and law enforcement. Criminal justice background from Fayetteville State University. The Chronicle's primary FOIA and public records specialist. More →

← New Forensic Analysis Challenges Jeffrey Epstein’s Death Ruling as Suicide US Loses Measles Elimination Status Amid Rising Outbreak Under Trump and RFK Jr. →
Mount Olive Chronicle

Independent local news for Wayne County, Duplin County, and the greater Mount Olive community in eastern North Carolina. Founded to serve the people and neighborhoods that deserve consistent, credible coverage.

📧 news@mountolivechronicle.com

📍 Mount Olive, North Carolina 28365

Sections

About

Legal

Search

© Mount Olive Chronicle. All rights reserved. Independent journalism for eastern North Carolina. Not affiliated with the former Mount Olive Tribune.